• LinkedIn
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  •   office@oilandgascorrosion.com        +44 (0) 114 4000850

Oil & Gas Corrosion

  • Home
  • About Us
  • Services
  • Case Studies
  • NACE MR0175
  • FAQs
  • Contact Us
  • alloyselect

What is the difference between pressure containing and pressure retaining parts? and how does NACE MR0175 apply?

14th March 2016

Viewed 7359 Times

ANSI / NACE MR0175/ISO 15156 defines a pressure-containing part as follows:

part whose failure to function as intended results in a release of retained fluid to the atmosphere

EXAMPLES Valve bodies, bonnets and stems.

NACE MR0175 does not provide an exhaustive list of “pressure containing parts”. Some users require a definite definition between pressure-containing parts and pressure-retaining parts. Regardless of a design code definition of pressure containing or pressure retaining parts,  NACE MR0175, in part 1 Clause 5, states that the equipment user shall determine whether or not the service conditions are such that NACE MR0175 applies and to ensure that any material specified for use is satisfactory in the service environment. This means that the equipment user must identify which parts require compliance with NACE MR0175 (including pressure containing and pressure retaining parts).

At Oil & Gas Corrosion, we get this question all the time “What is the difference between pressure-containing and pressure-retaining parts?”. The answer to this will depend on the applicable regulatory framework and design codes, nevertheless we have put together a few examples of how these parts are defined according to relevant references.

ASME PTC 23
  • Pressure Containing Member: A component which is exposed to and contains pressure
  • Pressure Retaining Member: A component which holds one or more pressure containing members together but is not exposed to the pressure.
Various documents from API such API 16A, API 16AR, API Std 674 These API documents follow a very similar approach:

  • A pressure-containing part is exposed to the fluid exerting the pressure and failure to function as intended results in release of fluids. These parts act as a barrier between the fluid and the environment.
  • A pressure-retaining part is not exposed to the fluid exerting the pressure, it is stressed due to the effects of a differential pressure, failure to function as intended results in release of fluids.
API 6X
  • pressure-containing: component whose failure to function as intended results in a release of retained fluid to the atmosphere.
  • pressure-retaining is not included in this document.
Pressure Equipment Directive (PED) 2014/68/EU (formerly97/23/EC)
  • PED 2014/68/EU does not address pressure containing or retaining parts, the term used is “pressure-bearing parts”. The main pressure-bearing parts are the parts, which constitute the envelope under pressure, and the parts which are essential for the integrity of the equipment.

These are just some examples of how pressure-containing and pressure retaining parts are defined in different codes. When pressure equipment is exposed to sour service conditions, the equipment user must define which parts need to comply with the relevant materials requirements such as NACE MR0175 or NACE MR0103. There is no general rule that covers all possible scenarios and as such, a materials engineer must review which pressure-containing and pressure-retaining parts have to comply with NACE MR0175.

At Oil & Gas Corrosion we help manufacturers and users to carry out a material selection review for their design and to identify the parts that need to meet the requirements of NACE MR0175 / ISO 15156.

We can help you review and document that your design complies with NACE MR0175 / ISO 15156 and the relevant regulatory requirements such as ASME VIII, PED 2014/68/EU, etc.

 

Talk to our team today!

  Email Us

USA toll-free

Live Chat

Contact us to find out more. In the US call our toll-free number 877.399.1010 and in the UK call 0114 4000850; or use our webchat for online materials and corrosion support.

Oil and Gas Corrosion Ltd is an independent materials and corrosion consultancy for the Oil and Gas industry. Oil and Gas Corrosion Ltd is under the guidance of Ivan Gutierrez. Ivan has more than 20 years’ experience in materials and corrosion and is a member of the National Association of Corrosion Engineers (NACE), a professional member of the Institute of Corrosion (MICorr) and the Society of Petroleum Engineers (SPE). He is a recognised materials and corrosion authority recognised as a Great Britain national expert member of the British Standard Institution committee PSE/17/67/7 “Corrosion Resistant Materials” and internationally as a member of Task Group 299 on the Oversight of Maintenance Panel for NACE MR0175 / ISO 15156. “Materials for use in H2S-containing environments in oil and gas production”, IOGP 15156 Committe (ISO/TC 67/WG 7 “Corrosion Resistant Materials”. Ivan is also a member of ISO/TC 67/WG 8 Materials, corrosion control, welding and jointing, and non-destructive examination (NDE) which is responsible for standards such as ISO 21457 “Materials selection and corrosion control for oil and gas production systems”. Oil & Gas Corrosion has headquarters in the United Kingdom providing services to clients across the globe.

 

In 2003 an inquiry was sent to the NACE MR0175 Maintenance Panel:

Question: Definition of pressure-containing parts: “Those parts whose failure to function as intended would result in a release of retained fluid to the atmosphere. Examples are valve bodies, bonnets, and stems.” Are stems always defined as pressure-containing parts, regardless of features that by design keep the stem intact? Example #1: Internal entry stems for ball valves that have a shoulder that rests against the body around the stem bore. Example #2: Shafts for butterfly valves that have a retaining ring holding the shaft inside the valve.

Answer:

The NACE MR0175/ISO 15156 maintenance panel cannot interpret design issues.

This question is in relation to NACE MR0175/ISO 15156-2 Clause 3.14

Reference: ISO 15156 Maintenance Panel Inquiry #2003-12 Q2.

Was this answer helpful ? Yes / No

Blog

Consultoría Técnica para la norma NACE MR0175 en español

3rd February 2019

...
READ

What is the difference between NACE MR0175 and NACE MR0103?

1st February 2019

...
READ

Users of BP Cassandra excel file have migrated to cloud solutions.

23rd January 2019

...
READ

How to use NORSOK M-506 Edition 3: 2017 to calculate corrosion rate?

4th January 2019

...
READ

Environmentally Assisted Cracking in Upstream Oilfield

1st August 2018

...
READ

Artificial Intelligence in materials selection of oil and gas assets.

31st July 2018

...
READ

View BLOG ➤

Tweets

  • What is the NACE MR0175 heat treatment? Ask our team of expert metallurgists https://t.co/4EhAAREMwJ, 4 hours ago
  • NACE MR0175 and the requirements for HSC, GHSC and SSC - We have the Technical Authority in Materials a... https://t.co/9F7IFUWjeY, 15 hours ago
  • NACE MR0175 and surface treatments to prevent SSC - Ask our corrosion consultants and metallurgists https://t.co/tzwxFYMQkD, Feb 16
Follow @oilgascorrosion ➤

Oil Prices



Oil and Gas Corrosion Ltd.
5 Smithfield
Sheffield
S3 7AR
United Kingdom
+44 (0) 114 4000850
US toll-free 877-399-1010

Privacy Policy   |   Website Terms & Conditions


© 2019 Oil & Gas Corrosion. Designed by Hunter Bevan..,.

try the online software for materials selection
  • try the online software for materials selection

  • alloyselect helps you select materials for sour service

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. more info

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.

Close